André Onana’s tenure at Manchester United has been disappointing, with high expectations following his signing. His first two seasons saw him struggle significantly, conceding 58 goals in his debut and underwhelming fans. Analysis highlights shortcomings in his skill set, relationships with coaching staff, and management influences. His recent loan to Trabzonspor symbolizes a decline from anticipated greatness. The narrative reflects broader challenges facing black goalkeepers in football and underscores the importance of support and improvement at elite levels.